Strategic recommendations to enhance sustainability in the logistics sector

The Indian logistics sector plays an important role in the economic development of India with a market value of USD 250 million in 2020. It is projected to rise to USD 380 million by 2025 with the rising demand in the manufacturing and e-commerce sector (KPMG, 2022). Providing jobs in distribution, warehousing, transportation and related services, the logistic sector has currently provided livelihood to more than 22 million people with the projection of an addition of 10 million more jobs by 2027 (IBEF, 2024).

Furthermore, India has made significant efforts to improve its global logistic performance as shown by the World Bank’s logistic performance index from 44^th position in 2018 to 38th in 2023 (World Bank, 2023). Despite these developments, the sector continues to face challenges in the form of high logistic costs. The 2022-23 economic survey showed that India’s logistic cost has been 14-18% of GDP compared to the global logistic cost of 8-10% (Debroy, 2024). Further, regulatory hurdles and inadequate infrastructure were other main challenges of the Indian logistic sector.

In the safety and sustainability context, the sector has witnessed pressure to adopt sustainability and safety practices that align with global standards. The logistic operations sustainability improvement is not just a means to fulfil corporate sustainability but a way of deriving brand reputation, regulatory compliance, and long-term viability (EY India, 2023). These factors are essential considering the demand of consumers, international trade partners and government.

Safety and sustainability incorporation in the logistics sector

Safety and sustainability incorporation refers to the process of integrating safety practices and sustainability principles into business operations, decision-making, and corporate strategies. This practice ensures that an organization operates in a manner that is not only safe for its employees, stakeholders, and communities but also environmentally responsible and sustainable over the long term.

However, while integrating safety and sustainability practices, companies have to bear challenges such as:

• High Initial Costs,
• Complex Regulations,
• Cultural Resistance,
• Balancing Profitability,
• Supply Chain Management,
• Technological Limitations, and
• Measuring Impact.

Though these challenges seem to be very complex and difficult to handle for many companies, the management of these challenges is essential for adhering to local and international safety and environmental regulations, having operational cost savings, preventing accidents and reducing waste, increasing trust and brand loyalty, and improving the overall well-being of employees. The goal of providing sustainability and safety in operations helps in addressing growing environmental concerns and regulatory demands. Thus, to meet India’s target of 2070 net zero emissions (Climate Action Tracker, 2024), the examination of sustainability and safety incorporation in the Indian logistics industry is essential.

Statistical analysis of the Indian logistic sector

Based on the analysis in previous articles, it was derived that companies in the logistics sector generally underperform in several key areas. For instance, the employment of differently abled individuals is notably low across most companies, with even the highest representation, Container Corporation, only reaching 2%. Other firms like Reliance Industries, Mahindra Logistics, and TCI Express show less than 0.5% representation. Similarly, the reuse and recycling of e-waste across companies are insufficient. While Blue Dart Express recycles 60% of its e-waste, it remains the only company showing strong performance in this area. Other companies are either not well reported or perform poorly, indicating a lack of effort in following sustainable practices.

Major contributors to poor performance are companies like TVS Supply Chain and Gateway Distriparks, both of which display low inclusion of differently abled and female employees. Furthermore, their lack of e-waste and hazardous waste management data suggests an insufficient commitment to sustainability.

Trends shaping Indian logistic companies

Indian logistic companies are generally shaped by different key aspects. One of them is the digitalization and automation through the usage of blockchain, IoT, and AI which contributes to improving real-time tracking. Further, with the e-commerce boom, e-commerce sales are expected to be USD 58.97 billion in 2024, increasing demand for last-mile delivery-based innovations (Silver Needle Ventures, 2024; Statista, 2024). Also, sustainability has been a growing focus with the adoption of green logistics amid India’s target of net zero emissions by 2070 (Climate Action Tracker, 2024). Further, the COVID-19 pandemic intensified the demand for e-commerce i.e. 25% in FY 21 (Vinaykumar, 2021), prompting logistical companies to adopt rapid technological shifts. However, this also exposed disparities in technological adoption.

The statistical examination of the logistic companies showed that companies with better digital infrastructure (like Blue Dart) managed to improve their sustainability efforts, particularly in waste management i.e. waste recycling increased from 11.46 metric tonnes in FY 2022-23 to 14.51 metric tonnes in FY 2023-24 (Blue Dart Express Limited, 2024). Meanwhile, policy changes promoting diversity and environmental responsibility (e.g., government pushes for increased female workforce participation and waste disposal regulations) led to minor improvements, as seen in companies like Reliance and Blue Dart Express (Reliance Industries Limited, 2024; Blue Dart Express Limited, 2024). Further, Blue Dart Express leads in e-waste management, driven by internal sustainability policies. On the other hand, companies like TVS Supply Chain and Gateway Distriparks lag due to either technological limitations or a lack of dedicated environmental and diversity policy. Their inaction is likely driven by cost constraints or a focus on short-term financial gains over long-term sustainability.

These trends indicate that while some companies are progressing in sustainability and workforce diversity, others lag significantly. The lack of inclusion and sustainability practices not only hampers companies’ operational efficiency but also affects their corporate image and compliance with new regulations. For workers, it means fewer opportunities for underrepresented groups, potentially perpetuating inequality. Lastly, for society, this could result in increased environmental degradation and slower progress toward social justice. Thus, presently the logistics industry despite being an important contributor to the economy still lags in its corporate sustainability level, especially for sustainability and safety. To counter this there is a need for implementing strategies which could support the overall sector and the companies in enhancing their performance.

Actionable strategies for the logistics sector

Increase Workforce Diversity through Hiring Initiatives: To address the stark underrepresentation of women and differently-abled individuals, logistics companies should adopt inclusive hiring practices like dedicated recruitment drives, diversity training, and flexible work policies. This is essential as it is reported that diverse companies are 35% more likely to perform better than competitors and even reduce employee turnover rate which results in cost savings in terms of training and recruitment (InStride, 2024).

Strengthen E-Waste Management and Sustainability Practices: Implementing better e-waste management strategies is crucial for sustainability by focusing on recycling and reusing electronic waste. These efforts will help in reducing the operational costs of companies (Khoa & Nhung, 2020).

Adopt Technology to Bridge Operational Inefficiencies: Technological gaps hinder progress in many logistics firms. Investment in technologies like IoT could help in reducing logistic costs by 10-15% and improve operational efficiency by 20% (Vorecol, 2024). Further, automation and AI usage could reduce unplanned logistic costs saving up to €3.5 million per year (Tina, 2023).

Promote Gender Equity through Leadership Development Programs: Encouraging female participation, particularly in leadership roles, can be achieved by offering leadership development programs tailored for women and establishing mentorship networks to support career advancement. The existence of more gender diversity in leadership could help in having companies outperformance by at least 21% compared to their counterparts in profitability (Dixon-Fyle et al., 2020).

Strategic pathways to sustainability in the Logistics Sector

One of the most glaring issues identified is the lack of workforce diversity across the industry. For instance, differently-abled individuals are underrepresented, with Container Corporation leading at a mere 2% and most other companies falling below 0.5%. Female representation is slightly better, with Reliance Industries showing nearly 60% of female participation. However, many other companies, such as TVS Supply Chain and Gateway Distriparks, have less than 20% female employees. Increasing workforce diversity should be a primary focus for all logistics companies to foster an equitable and inclusive work environment.

Further, Sustainability, particularly e-waste management, is another critical issue. Blue Dart Express leads the way by recycling 60% of its e-waste, while most other companies fail to report their waste management activities. There is a dire need for more companies to adopt robust e-waste recycling and reuse strategies to minimize environmental harm.

Both TVS Supply Chain and Gateway Distriparks should prioritize improving their workforce diversity by launching targeted recruitment drives for women and differently-abled individuals. With female representation under 20%, these companies are significantly lagging behind others in the sector. Initiatives like mentorship programs, flexible work policies, and leadership development for women would help improve gender diversity. Improving workforce diversity in these companies will have a profound impact on their corporate culture and operational effectiveness. Additionally, hiring differently-abled individuals can improve a company’s public image, aligning with corporate social responsibility (CSR) goals and meeting regulatory requirements. By focusing on gender and ability inclusivity, these companies can boost employee engagement, innovation, and retention.

Although Blue Dart Express leads in e-waste recycling (60%), its e-waste reuse rate is only 15%, leaving room for improvement. By setting higher benchmarks for e-waste reuse, Blue Dart can push for greater sustainability. Increasing Blue Dart’s e-waste reuse rate from 15% to 30% would significantly reduce environmental waste, contributing to its sustainability goals and helping the company maintain a competitive edge in the industry. Furthermore, setting these benchmarks would position Blue Dart as a global leader in logistics sustainability, attracting eco-conscious clients and enhancing its reputation. This also reduces costs associated with new raw materials, making operations more cost-efficient.

Aegis Logistics excels in hazardous waste disposal, with a 100% safe disposal rate. The company can broaden its sustainability initiatives by focusing on e-waste management, an area where it currently lacks. Establishing e-waste recycling goals and reporting transparency would reinforce their sustainability efforts and enhance their corporate reputation. While Aegis Logistics performs exceptionally well in hazardous waste disposal, expanding its efforts to include e-waste management would be a logical next step. This would help the company demonstrate a broader commitment to sustainability, which is increasingly demanded by consumers, investors, and regulatory bodies. Implementing a comprehensive e-waste recycling program could enhance Aegis’s sustainability profile and provide a strong competitive advantage in an industry where environmental responsibility is becoming a key differentiator.

By adopting these recommendations, the logistics sector can foster a more diverse, equitable, and sustainable future. Companies like TVS Supply Chain and Gateway Distriparks must prioritize workforce diversity to stay competitive, while Blue Dart Express and Aegis Logistics should enhance their sustainability efforts to lead the industry toward environmental responsibility. These measures will not only improve environmental outcomes and regulatory compliance but also foster a more inclusive workforce, contributing to higher employee satisfaction and retention.

References

• Blue Dart Express Limited. (2024). Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report (BRSR) for the Financial Year ended 31st March, 2024. https://nsearchives.nseindia.com/corporate/BLUEDART_25062024195742_SELETTERBRSR2506.pdf
• Climate Action Tracker. (2024). Net zero targets. https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/india/net-zero-targets/#:~:text=Target%20year%20%E2%80%93%20India%20aims%20to,key%20sectors%20of%20the%20economy.
• Debroy, B. (2024). Accurate data is the first step in bringing down logistics costs in India. Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/accurate-data-is-the-first-step-in-bringing-down-logistics-costs-in-india-9104060/
• Dixon-Fyle, S., Dolan, K., Hunt, D. V., & Prince, S. (2020). Diversity wins: How inclusion matters. In McKinsey & Company. https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/diversity-and-inclusion/diversity-wins-how-inclusion-matters
• EY India. (2023). Transforming the future of Indian logistics sector. https://www.ey.com/en_in/insights/consulting/transforming-the-future-of-indian-logistics-sector
• IBEF. (2024). Transforming India’s logistics sector: challenges and opportunities. India Brand Equity Foundation. https://www.ibef.org/research/case-study/transforming-india-s-logistics-sector-challenges-and-opportunities
• InStride. (2024). Diversity in the workplace Statistics to know for 2024. https://www.instride.com/insights/workplace-diversity-and-inclusion-statistics/
• Khoa, H. D., & Nhung, T. T. B. (2020). Green logistics application to reduce operating costs for Vietnam logistics enterprises. Business & IT, X(1), 2–11. https://doi.org/10.14311/bit.2020.02.01
• KPMG. (2022). The logistics and warehousing market in India. https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/in/pdf/2022/10/The-logistics-and-warehousing-market-in-India.pdf
• Reliance Industries Limited. (2024). Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report for the financial year 2023-24. https://nsearchives.nseindia.com/corporate/kavinavora_07082024144352_SE_BRSR.pdf
• Silverneedle Ventures. (2024). India’s Last-Mile Delivery Boom: Numbers that deliver dreams. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/indias-last-mile-delivery-boom-numbers-deliver-dreams-gj3dc/
• Statista. (2024). ECommerce – India. https://www.statista.com/outlook/emo/ecommerce/india
• Tina. (2023). Artificial intelligence (AI) in supply chain and logistics. ThroughPut Inc. https://throughput.world/blog/ai-in-supply-chain-and-logistics/
• Vinaykumar, R. (2021). Online shopping in India gets pandemic boost, e-retail market grows 25% in FY21. Business Today. https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/economy/story/online-shopping-in-india-gets-pandemic-boost-e-retail-market-grows-25-in-fy21-304340-2021-08-17
• Vorecol. (2024). Integrating IoT devices into supply chain optimization software. https://vorecol.com/blogs/blog-integrating-iot-devices-into-supply-chain-optimization-software-172544#:~:text=Imagine%20a%20scenario%20where%20a,costs%20by%2010%2D15%25.
• World Bank. (2023). Logistics Performance Index (LPI). https://lpi.worldbank.org/international/global