Impact of Real Estate Regulation and Development Act (RERA) on India’s real estate sector
The Real Estate Regulation and Development Act (RERA) 2016 is a revolutionary Act in the history of the Indian real estate sector. It was introduced first in the year 2013, but due to objections raised in the parliament, it came into effect only in May 2016. Furthermore, it was introduced to protect home buyers’ interests and also to boost investment in the real estate sector. The Act aims to improve transparency and encourage fair practices in the sector.
Reasons for introducing RERA
Indian real estate sector has been facing a slump since 2012. This is due to factors like:
- inventory pile-up,
- low rental yield,
- unclear taxes and arbitration.
However, the property prices have not stabilised accordingly (The Indian Express, 2017). As a result, the demand for property has decreased further. This reduced demand is causing a slowdown in the recovery of investment for builders.
The major issue facing the sector is lack of transparency. The system until recently was opaque with regards to price, construction delay, construction quality, ownership (title) and litigations. Of these, the biggest issue is the delay in the delivery of property to buyers. During the last two decades, the number of under construction properties rose to an all-time high. Particularly in major cities, many builders have flouted norms by failing to keep up with project deadlines (The Economic Times, 2017). For a homebuyer investing his life savings in the property, indefinite delays are a cause for worry.
Property agents or brokers took advantage of prospective homebuyers by misinforming them about the quality of construction and completion. They misled homebuyers regarding amenities of the property. They would give assurances orally regarding property documents which were often missing or incomplete. Furthermore, the agents would hide the status of properties under litigation from prospective buyers (Sharma, 2017).
Scope of RERA
The Act applies to under-construction as well as new projects. Residential and commercial projects are included in its ambit. Real estate agents or brokers to are included in the purview of the Bill. The scope of the Bill covers all parties to a real estate transaction. The purpose is to ensure greater accountability and transparency in the system.
RERA requires all states in India to set up an Appellate Tribunal to address homebuyers’ grievances. The Act requires all builders to register their projects with the Tribunal before initiation. The registration process requires them to detail the design and state the deadline for completion. If the deadline is not met they are liable to compensate the buyers and face penalties and or criminal charges. Moreover, until recently most of them were diverting the funds to launch other new projects without completing ongoing ones. This used to cause a delay in ongoing projects due to lack of funds. Under the Act, builders are required to set aside 70% of the initial funds in an escrow account for construction of the property. This will ensure that projects are not held up due to lack of funds (Ghosh, 2016).
Impact of RERA on new projects
Any project with over 8 apartments or size of over 500 sq. mt. is required to be registered under RERA. The developers have to register each stage of construction independently with the State Tribunal. Since builders have to register their new projects, big players cannot pre-launch a project. Pre-launches used to be the major source for raising the capital (Mehta, 2016). It means the developers now have to borrow capitals at higher rates which will be ultimately bored by the consumers. Also, there is a cap on the number of deposit builders can accept from buyers. Under RERA a builder cannot take more than 10% as an initial deposit. Advertising a project without registering it first is also banned. The Act also addresses two major issues faced by buyers:
- delay in construction and
- quality of construction.
In both cases, if a builder flouts on the RERA norms, he or she will be liable to compensate the buyer for the loss (Dhawan, 2017). The compensation is decided in the initial agreement signed between the parties. It also specifies the amount of interest payable by the builder in case of construction delays.
Impact of RERA on ongoing projects
The developers who still has under construction projects may face difficulty due to RERA. As per the Act, all the ongoing projects have to now register first with the regulatory authority before moving further in completing the project. They are also prohibited from advertising or promoting the property before registration (Kaushal, 2017). These steps are likely to delay the construction and sale of existing property greatly. RERA also mandates builders to issue occupation or completion certificate before handing over possession to the buyer. As of today, there are lakhs of flats in all major cities of India like Mumbai and Bangalore who have failed to do so. The further step to regularise such properties remains unclear. Another concern for these developers is whether they will get the certificates on time or not. Lastly, in cases where developers seek an extension, the amount of time granted for project completion would depend upon the authority (Mammen, 2017).
Impact of RERA on builders
Under RERA builders are mandated to register critical information regarding the project. This includes:
- promoter details,
- land title status,
- statutory approval status,
- details of the brokers,
- architects and contractors.
Failure to register this information will lead them to penalties. They are bound by a five-year agreement with the buyer for quality assurance. This means that within five years of selling a property if construction quality issues arise they will have to repair it. Moreover, they have to ensure the formation of Residents’ Welfare Association within three months of the project completion (Reddy, 2017). RERA clause that buyers can claim a refund in case of delay or dissatisfaction with property puts developers in a fix. In case many of them claim a refund in one go, it will affect developers badly as liquidity in construction and real estate is very low (Sinha, 2016).
Apart from disclosing critical information mentioned above to buyers, they also have to state the exact size (carpet area) of the property. They can no longer state super-built up area (i.e. common area, verandah, etc.) as the size of the property. Due to this they can no longer charge buyer the amount for a super built-up area. Therefore these charges will be passed on to the buyer as increased carpet area price. Also, it is expected that cost for developers will increase as they can start selling only after getting the approval. There will be consolidation in the market and thus, only a few players may exist (FE Online, 2017).
Currently, developers are postponing their new launches in order to understand the impact of RERA act and focus more on completing the existing projects. It means there will be fewer launches due to uncertainty. There were 73% fewer launches in the second half of 2016 as compared to the same period of 2015 (Ananthamurthy, 2016).
Impact of RERA on the buyers
RERA has been introduced mainly to protect the interest of property buyers. In order to increase transparency regarding project completion status, it mandates developers to disclose the construction status on the Authority website. This has to be done on a quarterly basis. In case of any misdoing by the developer, the buyer can file a complaint with the Authority. Their complaints are mandated to be resolved within 120 days. Finally, builders cannot change any aspect of the structure without prior approval from all the buyers (Business Today, 2017). All these measures, in addition to those mentioned the above section, are expected to boost investor confidence. The amount of unsold inventory in cities is likely to go down with RERA implementation.
Impact of RERA on Agents and brokers
Traditionally, the Indian real estate agents have been an unorganized segment of this sector. However, the new legislation makes it mandatory for the brokers to register themselves to facilitate a transaction. According to an estimate, there are 5,00,000-9,00,000 agents in India which has an unorganised and unregulated affair (Singh, 2017). Under RERA, brokers will no longer be able to sell properties unregistered with the Authority. They will also be penalised in case of wrong information given to buyers regarding the property. However, the fear among industry players is that many unorganised brokers will find themselves out of work. Agents need to pay a fee in order to register themselves. Moreover, in the case of builders floating on their promises, agents will be penalised. Citing issues of lack of faith on builders and lack of benefits for agents under RERA, many agents will choose to shut shop (Sapam, 2017).
Macroeconomic impact of RERA
The RERA move coupled with Goods and Services Tax implementation is seen as a positive move for the sector. The main issues plaguing real estate in India were transparency and accountability, which have been tackled now. Such has been the impact of RERA that when the website was launched in Uttar Pradesh state, 15000 complaints were registered in a single day from Noida region alone (Bhowmick, 2017). However, the response in some states to RERA has been dissatisfactory. In Haryana, buyers have complained that they are excluded from RERA if they have already moved into the property. Thus, they cannot file a complaint about lack of services or amenities provided by the builder (Jha, 2017). The full effect of RERA will come only after a year since each state is setting up its independent legislation and a standardised measure for success will take time to build.
- Ananthamurthy, H. (2016) IMPACT OF RERA – THE REAL ESTATE (REGULATION AND DEVELOPMENT) ACT, Experion .
- Bhowmick, S. (2017) ‘Over 15,000 complaints lodged on UP-Rera site by day end’, Times of India, 26 July. Available at: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/noida/over-15000-complaints-lodged-on-up-site-by-day-end/articleshow/59775814.cms.
- Business Today (2017) ‘What is RERA and how will it benefit home buyers?’, Business Today, May. Available at: http://www.businesstoday.in/current/economy-politics/homebuyers-developers-builders-carpet-area-delay-possession/story/251235.html.
- Dhawan, S. (2017) RERA: Are on-going realty projects being covered under RERA in your state?, The Economic Times.
- FE Online (2017) 5 ways RERA will impact developers – The Financial Express, The Financial Express.
- Ghosh, S. (2016) ‘RERA takes effect; to address homebuyers grievances’, Hindustan Times, 4 May. Available at: http://www.hindustantimes.com/real-estate/takes-effect-to-address-homebuyers-grievances/story-A8h7PPTnbfR8769DJRpfTP.html.
- Jha, D. (2017) ‘Haryana’s RERA bill not in our favour: Gurgaon homebuyers’, Hindustan Times, 9 May. Available at: http://www.hindustantimes.com/gurgaon/haryana-bill-not-in-our-favour-gurgaon-homebuyers/story-9i9zef0TLwMsjfjQyY5ObL.html.
- K Mehta, V. (2016) How RERA, GST will impact real estate sector and home buyers – The Financial Express, The Financial Express.
- Kaushal, T. (2017) ‘RERA comes into effect: Here’s what it means for homebuyers’, Business Today, 2 May. Available at: http://www.businesstoday.in/money/real-estate/will-bring-immediate-relief-to-homebuyers/story/251295.html.
- Mammen, S. (2017) ‘Buyers Fear RERA May Delay Ongoing Projects’, Proptiger, 24 May. Available at: https://www.proptiger.com/guide/post/buyers-fear-may-delay-ongoing-projects.
- Reddy, S. (2017) Real Estate Regulations & Development Act (RERA) | Key points & Review, ReLakhs. Available at: https://www.relakhs.com/real-estate-act-key-points-review/.
- Sapam, B. (2017) ‘RERA may put most brokers out of work’, Live Mint, 29 May. Available at: http://www.livemint.com/Companies/inodSsmgGWal3mlLYW9pAO/may-put-most-brokers-out-of-work.html.
- Sharma, A. (2017) ‘What RERA means for real estate agents, under-construction projects’, Live Mint2, 26 April. Available at: http://www.livemint.com/Money/a6JheUfEvwEdFi6vCuv90K/Real-estate-agents-and-underconstruction-projects-need-to-r.html.
- Singh, V. (2017) How will RERA impact real estate agents? | Housing News, Housing.com.
- Sinha, P. (2016) Builder will pay you 10.9% interest if he delays delivery of your new home, Economic Times.
- The Economic Times (2017) ‘RERA comes into effect tomorrow: Here’s everything you need to know’, The Economic Times, 30 April. Available at: http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/wealth/real-estate/realty-act-rollout-from-may-1-but-states-yet-to-frame-rules/articleshow/58441744.cms.
- The Indian Express (2017) What is the Real Estate Regulation Act (RERA), The Indian Express.